As a detective trying to solve the mystery of the crossword clue “Overly sentimental fare,” my first instinct was to focus on the word “sentimental.” I began to think of different terms associated with the word “sentimental,” such as sappy,mushy, or syrupy. I then noticed that the word “fare” was included in the clue, which led me to believe that the answer may be a type of food or cuisine. Considering these factors, the word “slop” came to mind as a fitting answer. Slop is often associated with low-quality or unappetizing food, and can also be used to describe sentimental or emotional content that is excessive or overdone. Therefore, the answer “slop” fits perfectly with the clue, and helped me solve the mystery of the crossword puzzle.